Cricket Punt


Blog Layout

Let's talk about All Rounders

Neil Wyman • 15 February 2021

Taking a closer look at the Blast all rounders - Balls per boundary

When a franchise is putting together a team, there are different ways to be build the team. In my opinion the best balance is to have five out and out bowlers. In an ideal world one of them would including one of them left arm pace such as a Dwarshius or Topley. An unorthodox spinner (or 2) is a must and then the rest filled with the best bowlers available.

I am not a massive fan of all rounders in t20 cricket. It’s useful to have a world class bat like a Glenn Maxwell who is a 6th bowling option or high quality overseas options like D’Arcy Short for match ups but not essential.

When we look at all rounders there are four categories in my opinion, the genuine all rounder who would get in the team with his bowling or his batting. I think world wide there are only three of these, Hardik Pandya, Andre Russell (when fit) and Shakib Al Hasan.
 
Then the next category is the Batting all rounder. These players can sometimes be the 5th bowling option and expected to bowl 4 overs in weaker teams. Or two batsman fulfil the role of the 5th bowler. There is an extremely long list of these players, Stokes, Maxwell, Cutting, Root, Stirlling, Christian, Pollard, Stoinis, Watson, Neesham etc. First of all though these players are elite batsman who can bowl reasonably well. Most teams around the world get composed, especially in auctions, of these batting all rounder. Teams seem to over value, or over pick these players.

Then there are the all rounders, who in my opinion wouldn’t get in a normal team with either skill set. Think Carlos Brathwaite, Darren Sammy, Ravi Bopara, maybe who are both below the average in each department but in lower grade franchises these players can become important but they generally struggle at international or IPL level. 

Then there is the category that in my opinion is the most undervalued in world cricket and the one I want to focus on today. The elite bowler or bowler who is definitely bowling four overs who can also find the fence. Rashid Khan, Sunil Narine, Coulter-Nile, Hasan Ali and most recently Jhye Richardson are names who I think fulfil this role. These players to me are under utilised in t20 franchise cricket. The fact you would have these players in your team has multiple benefits. 

Firstly, it means your top order can be more aggressive as the fear or leaving too many balls to the tail is diminished. Secondly, they can also pinch in the powerplay, or in the middle overs if one of them possesses spin hitting ability like Narine. Thirdly, it also means you can trust these players to get you home in run a ball chases 6 down, such as Hasan Ali in the 3rd Pak v SA t20, but they may also win you a 12 or 13 rpo chase with a few overs to go occasionally.

This is a skillset that requires dedication and opportunity. Management first of all need to recognise the skillset then accept that the failure rate of these players will be high. But this should not matter, it’s almost a free bet. Teams rarely get bowled out. A team going at optimal aggression should be bowled out around 10% of the time batting first. Daniel Worrall recently showed in the BBL what can be done by a tailender whose only mindset is hitting boundaries. These players must have low balls per boundary numbers and / or high six percentages. 

I will talk about how I would set up a batting team to take advantage of the three batting phases in a future article. For now I would like to depth chart the Blast from last season and see how we can break up the players in to the four categories and see if there are any undrafted players who catch the eye.

So I have taken the data from the Blast last season. If you’re a batsman I rate balls per boundary extremely highly. Likewise the opposite should probably hold fairly true, if bowlers can prevent teams hitting the ball to the boundary then that is a useful skill. Obviously there is a number of limitations using this state, there are other important factors that I am not going to explore today such as non boundary scoring percentages. This is also a small data sets for some players, there is a recency bias as this is 2020 data and the data hasn’t been adjusted for the match or innings situations. This could all be done but would add many more hours so I am going to keep it simpler for now.

Let’s look at the All Rounders, these are players who are bowling frequently in games and batting.

Player Balls batted Balls bowled BPB Bat BPB Bowl E-D SR Econ
Joe Root 199 106 5.5 13.3 7.7 128.2 8.63
Adam Lyth 198 116 4.5 11.6 7.1 144.5 7.25
Will Jacks 210 199 5.0 11.1 6.1 144.8 7.22
Paul Walter 105 108 5.3 9.8 4.6 137.2 9.13
Benny Howell 45 110 3.0 7.3 4.3 124.9 6.96
Cameron Delport 169 89 4.7 8.9 4.2 139.7 8.03
Liam Livingstone 125 157 4.6 8.7 4.1 140.4 7.93
Delray Rawlins 166 91 5.5 9.1 3.6 139.2 7.33
Daniel Christian 124 216 4.8 7.7 2.9 139.6 8.4
Luke Hollman 101 144 7.2 9.6 2.4 139.0 6.79
Brydon Carse 114 157 5.4 7.5 2.0 146.0 8.62
Gareth Delany 140 105 4.8 6.6 1.7 142.3 7.31
Alex Hughes 90 128 6.9 8.5 1.6 119.3 8.01
Wayne Madsen 140 91 5.6 5.7 0.1 133.1 7.86
Dan Lawrence 139 85 6.0 6.1 0.0 139.2 7.46
Lewis Gregory 78 118 5.2 5.1 -0.1 145.1 8.93
Mattie McKiernan 59 109 6.6 6.4 -0.1 126.3 7.18
Player Balls batted Balls bowled BPB Bat BPB Bowl E-D SR Econ
Ian Holland 128 134 9.1 8.9 -0.2 131.1 7.52
Jordan Thompson 63 137 5.7 5.5 -0.2 151.9 9.01
Steven Croft 221 66 7.9 7.3 -0.6 122.9 7.43
David Wiese 202 71 6.1 5.5 -0.7 145.3 8.45
Josh Cobb 170 157 8.9 8.3 -0.7 131.5 7.84
George Garton 88 181 6.8 5.8 -0.9 115.7 8.24
Colin Ackermann 207 126 8.0 7.0 -1.0 120.1 6.93
Joe Denly 110 127 6.5 5.3 -1.2 122.0 7.93
Tom Taylor 86 99 5.7 4.5 -1.2 142.9 8.56
Brett D'Oliveira 114 136 8.1 6.5 -1.7 125.5 7.82
Matt Critchley 139 182 8.7 7.0 -1.7 120.0 7.8
Ryan Higgins 156 214 7.1 5.1 -2.0 132.4 8.85
Paul Coughlin 60 126 6.7 3.9 -2.7 137.0 9.58
Will Rhodes 103 55 7.4 4.6 -2.8 115.2 8.99
Luis Reece 108 94 8.3 4.9 -3.4 125.1 8.2
Ravi Bopara 132 71 13.2 7.9 -5.3 121.3 7.51

* SR and Economy are career T20 strike rates and economy

** BPB is balls per boundary



Some interesting names in there if unfiltered. Zaib comes out top with small sample data, not a player you would expect. He does tick a lot of boxes, being left handed helps. Certainly one to keep an eye on considering that his raw data isn’t that impressive, SR 120 and Econ 8.12. Luke Procter comes out second. The table above is filtered for players who have participated in 150 balls in the 2020 Vitality Blast so we get this table, but we do lose players such as Ben Mike, Rikki Clarke, David Willey.


Now the top player using this metric is Joe Root. I am surprised to see Delport and Livingstone in there as neither would bowl much at international level but at Blast level they get regular overs. Luke Hollman is a very interesting name in the list, clearly a young player breaking on the scene. In my opinion if he can get that balls per boundary down to under 6 than he is looking at being an elite all rounder.

At the bottom is Ravi Bopara. I watched him a lot in the t10 and how he gets contracts is unknown. 


Here is a look at the bowling all rounders

Player Balls batted Balls bowled BPB Bat BPB Bowl E-D SR Econ
Graeme van Buuren 50 203 6.3 11.3 5.0 117.5 6.9
Graeme White 58 240 4.1 8.3 4.1 141.3 8.0
Roelof van der Merwe 75 174 5.0 7.9 2.9 132.1 7.1
Steven Mullaney 38 162 7.6 10.1 2.5 141.9 7.9
Daryl Mitchell 44 171 6.3 8.6 2.3 118.7 7.7
Simon Harmer 60 236 6.7 8.7 2.1 129.0 7.6
Samit Patel 30 229 6.0 7.2 1.2 125.9 7.3
Ed Barnard 41 186 5.9 6.9 1.0 133.4 8.9
Jamie Overton 55 125 3.7 4.6 1.0 167.5 9.6
Marchant de Lange 59 135 6.6 6.4 -0.1 130.8 8.6
Henry Brookes 55 193 5.5 4.7 -0.8 120.5 8.9
Andrew Salter 39 216 7.8 6.5 -1.3 116.2 8.1
Tim Bresnan 40 159 6.7 4.8 -1.8 132.0 8.1
Nathan Buck 25 172 8.3 5.2 -3.1 90.9 8.8
Danny Lamb 70 172 11.7 7.8 -3.8 99.2 8.1
Liam Trevaskis 42 200 10.5 6.5 -4.0 100.0 7.2
Callum Parkinson 40 194 13.3 8.1 -5.3 100.0 7.6
Chris Wood 48 201 12.0 6.7 -5.3 101.6 8.3
Scott Steel 40 145 13.3 7.6 -5.7 132.4 6.9
Grant Stewart 84 234 14.0 6.5 -7.5 100.0 8.9
Tom Helm 33 209 33.0 5.2 -27.8 106.9 8.6
Player Balls batted Balls bowled BPB Bat BPB Bowl E-D SR Econ
Paul Stirling 159 48 4.2 12.0 7.8 142.4 7.3
Jack Leaning 149 36 6.2 12.0 5.8 133.9 8.8
Jake Libby 236 36 6.7 12.0 5.3 135.3 7.7


I am trying to see with these players if there are any diamonds in the rough that captains aren’t using enough or have the potential to be very good players.


Scott Steel is interesting. He’s only 21, he did well opening in 2019 but only had 6 games last year and was dropped. In an auction you might want to take a chance on him at base price as a back up. But in a draft you must pick the best player available in that slot. He’s the kind of player I would be scouting, and pointing out his weaknesses as there is the core of a good player there.


Generally, you need to have that balls per boundary below six. Graeme White is a player that ticks a lot of the boxes with a very high six % of 10.3 that we discussed in a previous article.


Jamie Overton is becoming a very good player and had an excellent t20 tournament. I’d be surprised if he isn’t one of the first picks. Some of the players in the list will lose out because of Brexit and the expiry of Kolpak deals such as Van Der Merwe.


Then there are players such as Ed Barnard who look ok with the bat but then they fail to be a good enough bowler in the first place. The main criteria is these bowling all rounders need to be good bowlers. I looked at Barnard’s numbers in a bit more detail and he clearly has a problem bowling to left handers that needs looking at. Over 45 blast games he conceded 9.7 runs to left handers with 38 Balls per wicket compared to 8.5 right handers and 20 BPW.  Work on this weakness and then he can be considered. To me this is a big red flag and even though his raw data is ok would make him unselectable for a franchise competition at this stage. He is only 25 though and with good coaching and more analysis say using CricViz to look in to this weakness he is definitely a player to watch out for if he can address that issue.


This BPB metric is just a starting point when looking at players data and obviously I am using a very small sample. There is one thing I like about this metric though a lot, it identifies players who are just not up to scratch. Lewis Gregory is not an all rounder looking at the data. The eye test watching England games and Big Bash also confirms this in my opinion. He has been extremely fortunate to have been handed the opportunities he has. Must have a good agent.


Before we finish I just want to look at a one more young name that I think could have an excellent future, 20 year old Luke Hollman. He ticks those boxes that we just love when looking at T20, Left Hand bat and a skiddy Legbreak bowler. He was in the England U19 World cup set up so no doubt will be getting the best coaching and career path and I am sure being part of the England set up at youth level will be invaluable in his development.


His economy to right handers is exceptional 6.6. His captain, Steven Finn, leading a very young team with no internationals, was extremely conservative about how he used him last year, carefully picking him for matchups with right handers almost exclusively. His batting was good, going at 157 strike rate in the death overs which is decent for a young cricketer. I think this summer he needs to get some more cricket under his belt and then demand the ball in more difficult circumstances, ask to bowl against their best bowlers and be confident he can take wicket as well as occasionly when required bowling in the powerplay and working on his non stock deliveries. From a batting point of view he needs to push his case for batting at 5 and come in a bit earlier in the innings to really show his skillset. Middlesex have a gem that needs polishing so it's up to them and the England set up to get this player the exposure required.


Is he ready for franchise cricket? Probably not, he might sneak in the 14th or 15th spot in the hundred. But if he can improve this season and gain game experience versus lefties, and get the six percentage up a bit and / or reduce his balls per boundary into the elite level that would make him a real all rounder given his left hander and legbreak combo, exactly what coaches and captains value the highest.


Finally, there are three batsman that I included who had good numbers from a very small sample of balls bowled in the blast. Striling, Leaning and Libby. They can provide a 6th bowling option and these players should be encouraged to work on their skillsets in the nets to increase their usefullness to franchises.


If there's anything cool you saw in the data give me a buzz. If you loved the article please retweet. 


Thanks very much


 Neil


by Neil Wyman 25 February 2021
The draft came and went on Monday, but one of the names that wasn’t picked up was Gloucestershire captain, Jack Taylor. Taylor the niche finisher? Taylor operates in an interesting niche in the in the t20 world – the finishers, but more specifically, the seam finisher. This is a highly specialised role, batting at 5 or 6, where players are expected to get their team over the line chasing, or if setting go at at least 10+ runs per over in the last 3-5 overs of the innings. A lot of franchises double this role up with a 5th / 6th choice bowler and fill the team with these in the 5-8 slots. The modern team generally now has 4 specialist bats, a batting keeper, 4 specialist bowlers and 2-3 all rounders who either fill the 5th bowling option or combine as a 6th bowler for specific match ups. Examples of these players include Ben Cutting, Carlos Brathwaite, Keiron Pollard. Therefore, for Taylor to be noticed and stick his head above the parapet as a non bowling finisher you need to be elite to get drafted.
the hundred draft
by Neil Wyman 8 February 2021
The Hundred Draft - taking a closer look at the 2020 Blast Season and who may or may not get drafted. Batsman statistics in the 2020 Blast Season
ian cockbain hundred draft
by websitebuilder 8 February 2021
My initial research on the Hundred batsman came up with a few names like Hain, Bell-Drummond and Luke Hollman. One name that kept coming out though was Ian Cockbain, so I am going to take a closer look at his numbers over the last three seasons to see what we can learn about this player.
vitality blast
by Neil Wyman 8 February 2021
I was thinking about what makes a great bowler in t20 cricket. Some of the obvious metrics are bowling economy, strike rate, balls per wicket. There’s been work done on True Strike Rates that give each ball an expected outcome and how you perform over time against the average gives you a true performance level. This is fantastic but not everyone has access to an all singing, all dancing models. In the article about batting, I picked out three key metrics than can be used to assess players which I believe are important. So it makes some sense that if bowlers can restrict these then they must be fairly valuable. Here are the three metrics but in reverse for the bowlers, a) the best 1st 10 balls strike rate, b) best strike rate to set batsman who have faced over 18 balls and c) the lowest six percentage. Obviously these figures are not perfect, if someone played all their games at the MCG their six % would be artificially low or if they were at Taunton artificially high but if we inclined we could adjust for that and give each ground a six rating and then apply it to the player. I won’t be doing that today but I could make that data privately available should anyone be particularly interested. Furthermore the data set is small, so analysing one season like this will give rise to a recency bias. You might get taken down by Colin Munro on one day and all of a sudden your statistics look bad. Anyway, let's take a look at the worst offenders in the t20 blast last season 1. Strike rate to batsman facing their 1st 10 balls
Share by: